A pint glass of deep copper-red Irish red ale with a creamy off-white head on a wooden bar (AI-generated image)

Red Trolley Ale – Beer Review

Posted by:

|

On:

|

Red Trolley Ale is the beer that made Karl Strauss famous, and it has been doing it for more than three decades. It started life as the brewery’s first holiday ale, and it grew into one of the most award-winning beers Karl Strauss has ever brewed. Every batch is still brewed with a half-ton of caramelized malts, which is the part that gives the beer its deep copper color and its toffee-sweet backbone. If there is a single beer that defines what Karl Strauss does best, this is the one.

The basics

  • Brewery: Karl Strauss Brewing Company (San Diego, CA)
  • Style: Irish Red Ale
  • ABV: 5.8%
  • IBU: 17

What to expect

Red Trolley pours a deep copper red with a creamy off-white head. The nose is rich toffee and caramel malt, with hints of raisins and currants underneath. On the palate it is malty and smooth, the caramel sweetness leading the way and an earthy Willamette hop character keeping it from getting heavy. The finish is dry and clean for a beer this malty, which is why a pint disappears faster than you expect. It is not a beer that tries to impress you with intensity. It wins you over by being exactly what it promises: a well-made, malt-forward red ale that tastes like it has been brewed the same way for thirty years, because it has.

Our rating

7.0/10

Rated by Sam (7) and Alex (7). Sam and Alex both gave Red Trolley a 7, and we agree with them both. This is a benchmark Irish red ale, and the toffee and caramel character is done as well as anyone in San Diego does it. But it is also a beer that rewards a pint at the pub more than it rewards deep thinking. It is dependable, smooth, and easy to like, and it never quite reaches for anything more. That is not a flaw in a beer like this. It is the whole point, and it is why Red Trolley has lasted thirty years while flashier beers came and went.

Sources: BeerAdvocate, “Red Trolley Ale | Karl Strauss Brewing Company”, https://www.beeradvocate.com/beer/profile/4146/6428/ ; Draft Magazine, “Red Trolley Ale Review”, https://draftmag.com/red-trolley-ale-review/ . Note: our spreadsheet listed this beer as an Amber Ale at 6% ABV and 25 IBU; those values are wrong and have been corrected to Irish Red Ale, 5.8% ABV, 17 IBU.

Posted by

in

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *