A bright orange vanilla cream ale with a thick fluffy white head in a tall pint glass on a wooden patio table, with an orange slice and a vanilla bean beside it (AI-generated image)

Cali Creamin’ Creamsicle – Beer Review

Posted by:

|

On:

|

Cali Creamin’ Creamsicle takes Mother Earth’s flagship vanilla cream ale and gives it the orange twist, a year round beer built to taste like the ice cream truck classic it is named after. The brewery is upfront about the idea: the same base beer, plus orange and lactose, aiming for the flavor of a childhood creamsicle without making you chase down the ice cream man. It works better than a novelty beer has any right to, and it has stayed in the year round lineup ever since its release.

The basics

  • Brewery: Mother Earth Brew Co. (Vista, CA)
  • Style: Orange Vanilla Cream Ale
  • ABV: 5.0%
  • IBU: 18

What to expect

Cali Creamsicle pours a bright orange gold with a thick fluffy white head, and the nose is citrus and cream right away, orange peel over the vanilla base. On the palate it is medium bodied and creamy, with vanilla and orange peel leading and a gentle sweetness from the lactose that finishes just a touch sweeter than the regular Cali Creamin’. The orange brings a balancing citrus bitterness that keeps the sweetness in check, and the whole thing lands somewhere between an Orange Julius and a melted creamsicle, in the best way. The bitterness is low at 18 IBU, the alcohol barely registers at 5.0%, and the finish is clean enough that the glass empties faster than planned. It is a beer that knows exactly what it is and does not try to be anything else.

Our rating

8.25/10

Rated by Alex (8.5) and Nick (8). Alex runs a touch warmer than Nick here, and that is a strong score for a flavored cream ale, but it is deserved. The orange and vanilla play together cleanly, the lactose gives it body without making it heavy, and it delivers its theme without turning cloying. It loses half a point only because it is a one note beer by design, and that note is sweet. On a hot day, though, that note is exactly the right one.

Sources: Mother Earth Brew Co., “Our Beer”, https://www.motherearthbrewco.com/our-beer ; Guru of Brew, “Mother Earth Calicreamsicle Orange Vanilla Cream Ale Beer Review”, https://guruofbrew.com/mother_earth_calicreamsicle ; BeerAdvocate, “Cali Creamin’ Creamsicle | Mother Earth Brew Co.”, https://www.beeradvocate.com/beer/profile/22610/446901/ ; Brewbound, “Mother Earth Brewing Company Releases Cali Creamin’ Creamsicle”, https://www.brewbound.com/news/mother-earth-brewing-company-releases-cali-creamin-creamsicle/ . Note: our spreadsheet listed this beer at 5.5% ABV and 15 IBU; corrected to 5.0% ABV and 18 IBU per the brewery. Contains lactose.

Posted by

in

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *