A snifter glass of deep ruby-red imperial red ale with a thin creamy head and red grapes on a wooden bar (AI-generated image)

This One Goes to Eleven – Beer Review

Posted by:

|

On:

|

This One Goes to Eleven is Karl Strauss turning its holiday beer series up to the volume its name promises. It is the eleventh beer in the brewery’s annual 12 Days series, released for the 2020 holidays, and it is one of the strangest beers Karl Strauss has ever brewed. Brewmaster Paul Segura built it around Cabernet Sauvignon grape must, an ingredient he loved from one of the brewery’s long-gone anniversary ales, and the result is a beer that drinks like a red ale crossed with a glass of red wine.

The basics

  • Brewery: Karl Strauss Brewing Company (San Diego, CA)
  • Style: Imperial Red Ale
  • ABV: 9%
  • IBU: Not published

What to expect

This One Goes to Eleven pours a deep ruby red with a thin, creamy off-white head. The nose is red fruit and cereal grains, with grape jam leading the way. On the palate it is malty and amber-sweet at first, with caramel and toffee notes that fans of Karl’s Red Trolley Ale will recognize, then the grape must steps in with jammy fruit character and a wave of tannins that dries the finish out. The brewery describes a slightly dry, French-oak finish, and that is exactly what you get: a beer that ends more like a wine than a red ale. At 9% it is built to be cellared, and the brewers say it pairs with anything you would serve alongside a robust red wine.

Our rating

6.0/10

Rated by Alex (6). Alex gave this one a 6, and we think that lands about right. This One Goes to Eleven is a genuinely interesting beer, and the grape must gives it a character you will not find in any other San Diego red ale. But interesting is not the same as delicious, and the wine tannins pull the beer in a direction that fights its own malt sweetness instead of complementing it. It is a fun holiday experiment and a conversation piece, but as a beer to reach for again, it leaves us wanting the cleaner, malt-forward red ale underneath to take charge.

Sources: San Diego Beer News, “Beer of the Week: This One Goes to Eleven”, December 18, 2020, https://sandiegobeer.news/beer-of-the-week-this-one-goes-to-eleven/ ; BeerAdvocate, Karl Strauss Brewing Company beer list (Imperial Red Ale, 9% ABV), https://www.beeradvocate.com/beer/profile/4146/?view=beers . Note: our spreadsheet listed this beer as a Double IPA at 8.5% ABV and 70 IBU; those values are wrong and have been corrected to Imperial Red Ale, 9% ABV, with IBU not published.

Posted by

in

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *