A goblet of dark mahogany Belgian quadrupel ale with a thick creamy tan head, with dried figs, dates and toffee on a wooden table in a brewery taproom (AI-generated image)

Two Tortugas – Beer Review

Posted by:

|

On:

|

Two Tortugas is Karl Strauss playing the long game with a holiday beer. It was the second beer in the brewery’s 12 Days series, first released as a limited holiday ale in 2011, and it became one of the most decorated beers Karl Strauss has ever made. A bronze at the 2011 Great American Beer Festival, a silver at the 2012 World Beer Cup, and a gold at the 2018 Los Angeles International Beer Competition later, it is now a seasonal regular that returns most years, with a barrel-aged version appearing for the brewery’s 28th anniversary. It is a Belgian-inspired quadrupel, and it does not hide its strength.

The basics

  • Brewery: Karl Strauss Brewing Company (San Diego, CA)
  • Style: Belgian Quadrupel
  • ABV: 11.1%
  • IBU: 25

What to expect

Two Tortugas pours a deep mahogany brown with a thick, creamy tan head. The nose is toffee and dark fruit, with fig, raisin and plum layered over a warming spice note. On the palate it is rich and sweet, with dark Belgian candy sugar driving a toffee and dark fruit core, and Belgian abbey yeast adding a gentle spice and a touch of warmth. The body is full and the finish is long, with the 11.1% alcohol making itself known as a slow, warming presence. The brewery says the beer will continue to develop with age, and at this strength it is built to be laid down rather than rushed.

Our rating

4.0/10

Rated by Alex (4). Alex gave this one a 4, and we understand why. Two Tortugas has an impressive medal case and a flavor profile that reads beautifully on paper, but in the glass it is a heavy, sweet, boozy quad that leans hard into its own richness and never quite finds balance. The toffee and dark fruit pile up, the alcohol warms the throat more than it should, and one small pour feels like enough. Quad lovers who like their dark Belgian ales big and sweet may enjoy it more than we did, but for us this is a beer to split with friends on a cold night, not one to order twice.

Sources: Brewbound, “Karl Strauss Releasing Three Beers Over Next Three Months” (brewery label copy: 11% ABV, 35 SRM, 25 IBU; toffee, dark fruits, warming spices), August 29, 2011, https://www.brewbound.com/news/karl-strauss-releasing-three-beers-over-next-three-months/ ; BeerMenus and TapHunter (11.1% ABV), https://www.beermenus.com/breweries/1335-karl-strauss-brewing-company and https://www.taphunter.com/brewery/karl-strauss-brewing-company/4025 ; PRWeb, “Karl Strauss Takes Home a Bronze at World Beer Cup and a Gold at LA International Beer Competition”, May 11, 2018. Note: our spreadsheet listed this beer as a 4.8% Mexican-style lager; those values are wrong and have been corrected to Belgian Quadrupel, 11.1% ABV, 25 IBU.

Posted by

in

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *