Hammerhead Ale has been on tap at McMenamins since 1986, which makes it older than most of the breweries we review and one of the two beers the Portland brewpub chain has never taken off the menu. It was created in the company’s early years alongside Ruby Ale, first bottled in 1997, and put into 16 oz cans in 2016. It is still available year round at every McMenamins location, and it is still their top selling beer. That kind of staying power usually means a beer is either very good or very familiar. In Hammerhead’s case, it is a bit of both.
The basics
- Brewery: McMenamins (Portland, OR)
- Style: American Pale Ale
- ABV: 6.0%
- IBU: 44
What to expect
Hammerhead pours a rich chestnut copper-amber with a creamy off-white head that holds and laces down the glass. The nose is all Cascade: dry citrus and pine over a considerable sweet malt aroma, the caramel tones from the crystal malt announcing themselves before the first sip. On the palate the beer follows the nose, with an intense hopped flavor balanced against caramel malt sweetness, a medium body, and a clean, lightly bitter finish. The alcohol barely registers at 6.0%, and the bitterness reads softer than the 44 IBU suggests. Several reviewers note it drinks more like an English pale ale or ESB than a modern hop bomb, the malt doing as much work as the hops. It is the kind of pale ale that was built for a second pint, not for a tasting flight.
Our rating
8/10
Rated by Alex (8). Alex gave this one an 8, and that feels about right. Hammerhead is a classic done properly: balanced, drinkable, and honest about what it is. It loses points only because it plays it safe, a malt-forward pale ale in a world that now expects its pale ales to shout. But as a pub beer, the kind you order without thinking and enjoy without analyzing, it is hard to fault. This is the beer to order when you walk into a McMenamins and want the house standard.
Sources: McMenamins, “Seasonal Bottle and Can Releases”, https://www.mcmenamins.com/Page.aspx?id=255 ; BeerAdvocate, “Hammerhead Ale | McMenamins Inc.”, https://www.beeradvocate.com/beer/profile/2104/7952/ ; Brewpublic, “McMenamins To Release Cans of Ruby and Hammerhead”, July 22, 2016, https://brewpublic.com/beer-releases/mcmenamins-to-release-cans-of-ruby-and-hammerhead/ . Note: our spreadsheet listed this beer at 5.4% ABV and 40 IBU; corrected to 6.0% ABV and 44 IBU per the brewery.

Leave a Reply